Welcome to The Mill Supper Club
Nestled in Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin, The Mill Supper Club offers a charming blend of traditional supper club vibes and flavorful dishes. Diners are welcomed with a rustic ambiance reminiscent of a simpler time, where hearty meals take center stage. Their standout offerings include perfectly pan-fried fish, savory broasted chicken, and delectable mushroom ravioli bathed in rich Alfredo sauce. The service is lauded for its warmth, making every guest feel special. With sides like buttery baby red potatoes and a well-curated salad bar, it's clear why patrons keep returning for the friendly atmosphere and exceptional value, embodying the essence of Midwestern hospitality.
-
4128 WI-42 WI-57, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235, United States4128 WI-42 WI-57, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235, United States Hotline: +1 920-743-5044
Welcome to The Mill Supper Club, a cherished gem nestled in the heart of Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin. Located at 4128 WI-42, WI-57, this supper club invites you to step back in time and savor the art of dining in a warm and inviting atmosphere. With a rich history of providing exceptional meals, The Mill Supper Club captures the essence of traditional supper club culture, offering a delightful blend of comfort food and genuine hospitality.
As you enter, you are greeted not just by the aroma of delicious food, but by friendly faces ready to make your experience memorable. The highlight of their menu is undoubtedly the pan-fried fish, a favorite among patrons, featuring options like delectable walleye and lake perch, perfectly cooked for a delightful crunch on the outside and a tender, moist interior. According to one satisfied customer, Doug Duensing, "the tartar sauce just sat there sad from not being used," a testament to the fish's exceptional flavor and preparation.
For those looking for classic comfort, their Sunday Night special of broasted chicken served with whipped potatoes, gravy, dressing, cranberry sauce, and coleslaw is a nostalgic feast that will transport you to a simpler time. Jessie Mehl encapsulates this charm by saying, "It was a bit like stepping back in time to a gentler era." The Mill Supper Club truly embodies the essence of community dining where every meal feels like a home-cooked gathering.
And let’s not overlook the array of mouthwatering desserts that round off your meal perfectly. From the rich Coconut Cream Pie to the Very Cherry Berry Torte, each sweet treat is crafted to delight your taste buds. With prices that reflect great value, you can indulge without feeling guilty — as noted by Nancy Deffenbaugh, who praised the overall experience and great pricing.
As you sip on one of their giant old-fashioned cocktails, enjoy the heartfelt service provided by the staff, known for making every visitor feel like a valued guest. Wiencek's review highlights this sentiment: "The only thing that made our meal better was the absolutely incredible service.” This emphasizes how The Mill Supper Club not only serves comforting food but also fosters a welcoming environment that makes diners feel at home.
Whether you’re after a casual fish fry on a Friday evening, or a comforting dinner on a Sunday night, The Mill Supper Club promises an experience that excellently combines delicious food, warm company, and nostalgic charm. Next time you find yourself in Sturgeon Bay, make sure to stop by. You may find yourself returning again and again.
Wow!!! This was a great supper club experience! We both had pan fried fish, I had the Walleye she had the lake perch. They were both cooked perfect! Spiced great, crispy outside, the tender moist inside .tarter sauce just sat there sad from not being used! Got a side of soup also, roasted red pepper with Gouda cheese. It was great too. They had a small salad bar, but all the right stuff on it! Don't need a huge one when you know what to put on it! Can't go wiring going here! Old fashioned was spot on also!
What a treat! This was our first time visiting a Supper Club, and we struck gold with our first one. From the moment we stepped through the door we were made to feel welcome. The bar maid was friendly and helpful. We were seated by a very nice man, and our server was so gracious. We had the Sunday Night special of broasted chicken, whipped potatoes with gravy, dressing cranberry sauce and coleslaw. The dinner rolls were so good. The meal was a very good value for the money. This place was a bit like stepping back in time to a gentler era. Absolutely loved it.
A wonderful restaurant supper club find! Never a fan of poutine, my entire world was changed with their curry poutine. Wow! The fish fry was delicious, giant affordable old fashions and the only thing that made our meal better was the absolutely incredible service provided by Dori. She is the gem of Sturgeon Bay! Thank you.
This is a great place to grab a Friday fish dinner! We come here and get the pan fried perch and it's delicious. Comes with a potato, coleslaw, and rye bread. Additionally, the service is great and the staff are wonderful. We have been coming for decades. The customers are old, so it's not hectic here.
Our server, Moy, was the best. Very professional- brought our food out with a few minutes between courses...perfect! Food was super good, hot and tasty. Old-fashiones were very good. Prices were . 83.00 for 2 dinners with appetizer.
Can't beat the Thursday surf and turff. Prime rib and perch, salad bar and a ice cold Polka king. Updated to a 5 star. Been going there close 2 15 years now. Always good! The family style chicken is awesome. Great owners and staff.
Wonderful all the way around! Amazing food. Great atmosphere and service. We had the chicken dinner special and it was served family style in darling dishes. Would highly recommend!
This was the first supper club I have been to. We entered the bar and both bartenders were very nice. We had beer and a couple of drinks that were fantastic. Very relaxed atmosphere and welcoming for newcomers. We had the fried fish that was so fresh tasting I would have assumed we were eating off the boat. I would recommend it for the drinks and food and service again and again.