The Mill Supper Club Menu (2025 Update)
Introducing The Mill Supper Club, a charming culinary gem nestled in Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin. This iconic establishment captures the essence of traditional supper clubs, providing an inviting atmosphere and an enticing menu. As you step through the doors, you are greeted by friendly staff and an ambiance reminiscent of a gentler era.
The menu features enticing options: savor the pan-fried lake perch or indulge in the walleye, both praised for their perfect crispness and moist interiors. Meat lovers can delight in the 14oz Angus ribeye or the 8oz filet mignon, expertly grilled to your preference. Don’t miss out on the Friday specials, showcasing beer-battered cod and a delightful seafood platter.
Pair your meal with a giant old-fashioned, and complete your experience with a visit to the salad bar, offering all the essentials. With its exceptional service and delicious fare, The Mill Supper Club promises a memorable dining experience that keeps patrons coming back for more.
FOOD - Appetizers
Cheese Curds
Yellow Curds Lightly Breaded and Fried Served with House Made Ranch
Currywurst Poutine
Shoestring Cut Fries, topped with Curds, Fried Wurst, and Curry Gravy
Deviled Eggs
Flammkuchen
Grilled Flatbread with Creme Fraiche Nutmeg Sauce Topped with Caramelized Onions and Crisp Bacone
Giant Pretzel
Served with Pub Mustard and House Made Beer Cheese Sauce
Onion Petals
Beer Battered and Fried to Golden Brown Served with House Spicy Aioli
Potato Pancakes
Reuben Wonton Bites
Wonton Wrapped Corn Beef, Cabbage, and Swiss Cheese Served with House Made Spicy Aioli
Cup Soup
Bowl Soup
FOOD - Soup
FOOD - Salads
Caesar Salad
Side Caesar Salad
Kids Salad Bar
Side Baked Potato
Side Loaded Baked
Side Risotto
Side VOD
Side Aspargus
Side Buttered Baby Reds
Side German Baby Reds
Side American Potato Salad (Friday Only)
Side Spatzel
Side Sweet & Sour Red Cabbage
Side Apple Sauce
Side Coleslaw
Side Beer Cheese Sauce
Side Lemon Caper Sauce
Side Jager Sauce
Side Alfredo Sauce
Side Pub Mustard
Side Ranch
ExtraTartar
Extra Sour Cream
Side Creme Friche
Side Mayo
Quart Slaw
Quart Potato Salad
FOOD - Sides/Extras
FOOD - Entrees
Filet Mignon
8oz Certified Angus Beef Tenderloin Grilled to Order
Ribeye
14oz Choice Angus Ribeye Grilled to Order
Shrimp Dinner
8 Shrimp Hand Breaded and Deep Fried to a Golden Brown or Sauteed in Garlic and Butter
Walleye (1)
Walleye (2)
Two Filets Lightly Breaded Served Deep Fried or Pan Fried
Perch (3)
Lake Perch Served Deep or Pan Fried
Perch (5)
Lake Perch Served Deep or Pan Fried
Whitefish Dinner
Served Broiled with Lemon Caper Butter, Cajun Style, or Deep Fried
Grilled Salmon
8oz Grilled Salmon Filet in a Seasoned Garlic Herb Butter
Mill Scallops
Sauteed Scallops served over Seasonal Asparagus with Bavarian Mustard Sauce and Tomato Tarragon
Chicken Jaeger Schnitzel
Hand Breaded Fried Chicken topped with Onion Mushroom Sour Cream Gravy Served with your choice of Buttered Baby Red Potatoes or Spatzle Kaese, and Sweet and Sour Red Cabbage
Wiener Schnitzel
Hand Breaded Fried Pork topped with Lemon Caper Sauce Served with your choice or Buttered Baby Red Potatoes or Spatzle Kaese, and Sweet and Sour Red Cabbage
Half Rack BBQ Baby Back Ribs
Full Rack BBQ Baby Back Ribs
Linguine Carbonara
Alfredo Pasta
Wide Pasta tossed with House Made Alfredo
Mushroom Ravioli
Tender Ravioli Stuffed with Portabella and Crimini Mushrooms, Mozzarella Cheese, Onion, and Garlic in Our House Made Alfredo Garnished with Cherry Tomato and Grilled Asparagus
Cajun Shrimp Pasta
FOOD - German/Pastas
FOOD - Sandwiches
Hamburger
Third Pound Burger topped with Fresh Tomato, Lettuce, and Onion
Schnitzel Sandwich
Choice of Pork or Chicken Schnitzel topped with Swiss Cheese, Braised Red Cabbage, and Bavarian Mustard on a Pretzel Bun
Chicken BLT
Choice of 6oz Grilled or Crispy Chicken Breast topped with Applewood Smoked Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, and Mayo
BBQ Bacon Blue Burger
Third Pound Burger topped with melted Blue Cheese Crumbles, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Tomato, Lettuce, and Onion
Boneless Wings
Kids Buttered Noodles
Kids Fried Shrimp (3)
Macaroni & Cheese
FOOD - Kids
FOOD - Desserts
Cherry Pie
Very Cherry Berry Torte
Kids Ice Cream Sundae
Coconut Cream Pie
Cheese Curds
Yellow Curds Lightly Breaded and Fried Served with House Made Ranch
Currywurst Poutine
Shoestring Cut Fries, topped with Curds, Fried Wurst, and Curry Gravy
Deviled Eggs
Flammkuchen
Grilled Flatbread with Creme Fraiche Nutmeg Sauce Topped with Caramelized Onions and Crisp Bacone
Giant Pretzel
Served with Pub Mustard and House Made Beer Cheese Sauce
Onion Petals
Beer Battered and Fried to Golden Brown Served with House Spicy Aioli
Potato Pancakes
Reuben Wonton Bites
Wonton Wrapped Corn Beef, Cabbage, and Swiss Cheese Served with House Made Spicy Aioli
Appetizers
Soup
Cup Soup
Bowl Soup
Caesar Salad
Side Caesar Salad
Kids Salad Bar
Salads
Sides/Extras
Side Baked Potato
Side Loaded Baked
Side Risotto
Side VOD
Side Aspargus
Side Buttered Baby Reds
Side German Baby Reds
Side American Potato Salad (Friday Only)
Side Spatzel
Side Sweet & Sour Red Cabbage
Side Apple Sauce
Side Coleslaw
Side Beer Cheese Sauce
Side Lemon Caper Sauce
Side Jager Sauce
Side Alfredo Sauce
Side Pub Mustard
Side Ranch
ExtraTartar
Extra Sour Cream
Side Creme Friche
Side Mayo
Quart Slaw
Quart Potato Salad
Filet Mignon
8oz Certified Angus Beef Tenderloin Grilled to Order
Ribeye
14oz Choice Angus Ribeye Grilled to Order
Shrimp Dinner
8 Shrimp Hand Breaded and Deep Fried to a Golden Brown or Sauteed in Garlic and Butter
Walleye (1)
Walleye (2)
Two Filets Lightly Breaded Served Deep Fried or Pan Fried
Perch (3)
Lake Perch Served Deep or Pan Fried
Perch (5)
Lake Perch Served Deep or Pan Fried
Whitefish Dinner
Served Broiled with Lemon Caper Butter, Cajun Style, or Deep Fried
Grilled Salmon
8oz Grilled Salmon Filet in a Seasoned Garlic Herb Butter
Mill Scallops
Sauteed Scallops served over Seasonal Asparagus with Bavarian Mustard Sauce and Tomato Tarragon
Entrees
German/Pastas
Chicken Jaeger Schnitzel
Hand Breaded Fried Chicken topped with Onion Mushroom Sour Cream Gravy Served with your choice of Buttered Baby Red Potatoes or Spatzle Kaese, and Sweet and Sour Red Cabbage
Wiener Schnitzel
Hand Breaded Fried Pork topped with Lemon Caper Sauce Served with your choice or Buttered Baby Red Potatoes or Spatzle Kaese, and Sweet and Sour Red Cabbage
Half Rack BBQ Baby Back Ribs
Full Rack BBQ Baby Back Ribs
Linguine Carbonara
Alfredo Pasta
Wide Pasta tossed with House Made Alfredo
Mushroom Ravioli
Tender Ravioli Stuffed with Portabella and Crimini Mushrooms, Mozzarella Cheese, Onion, and Garlic in Our House Made Alfredo Garnished with Cherry Tomato and Grilled Asparagus
Cajun Shrimp Pasta
Hamburger
Third Pound Burger topped with Fresh Tomato, Lettuce, and Onion
Schnitzel Sandwich
Choice of Pork or Chicken Schnitzel topped with Swiss Cheese, Braised Red Cabbage, and Bavarian Mustard on a Pretzel Bun
Chicken BLT
Choice of 6oz Grilled or Crispy Chicken Breast topped with Applewood Smoked Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, and Mayo
BBQ Bacon Blue Burger
Third Pound Burger topped with melted Blue Cheese Crumbles, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Tomato, Lettuce, and Onion
Sandwiches
Kids
Boneless Wings
Kids Buttered Noodles
Kids Fried Shrimp (3)
Macaroni & Cheese
Cherry Pie
Very Cherry Berry Torte
Kids Ice Cream Sundae
Coconut Cream Pie
Desserts
Thursday & Sunday Special - Thursday & Sunday Special
TOGO 4 Piece Chicken Dinner
4-Piece Mill Original Baked Chicken or Broasted Chicken with Whipped Potatoes, Dressing, Gravy, Cranberries, Coleslaw, and a Fresh Roll
TOGO 4 Piece Chicken Dinner
4-Piece Mill Original Baked Chicken or Broasted Chicken with Whipped Potatoes, Dressing, Gravy, Cranberries, Coleslaw, and a Fresh Roll
Thursday & Sunday Special
Wednesday Special - Wednesday Special
Schwenkbraten
14oz Center Cut Broasted Pork Chop with House Made Apple Chutney
Schwenkbraten
14oz Center Cut Broasted Pork Chop with House Made Apple Chutney
Wednesday Special
Friday Special - Friday Specials
Perch Special
Walleye Special
Beer Battered Shrimp Special
Deep Fried White Fish Special
Scallops Special
Beer Battered Cod
Seafood Platter
Perch Special
Walleye Special
Beer Battered Shrimp Special
Deep Fried White Fish Special
Scallops Special
Beer Battered Cod
Seafood Platter
Friday Specials
Saturday Special - Saturday Special
Prime Rib
Slow Roasted and served with choice of Side, Soup or Salad, and Fresh Rolls
Prime Rib
Slow Roasted and served with choice of Side, Soup or Salad, and Fresh Rolls
Saturday Special
Tuesday Special - Tuesday Special
Meatball Stroganoff
Thin Beef Roll Stuffed with Onion, Pickle, and Dijon Mustard Wrapped with Bacon and topped with Bavarian Sauce Served with your choice or Buttered Baby Red Potatoes or Spatzle Kaese, and Sweet and Sour Red Cabbage
Meatball Stroganoff
Thin Beef Roll Stuffed with Onion, Pickle, and Dijon Mustard Wrapped with Bacon and topped with Bavarian Sauce Served with your choice or Buttered Baby Red Potatoes or Spatzle Kaese, and Sweet and Sour Red Cabbage